Comments on: Scumbag Soldier Hurls Live Puppy in Sick YouTube Stunt

By: Eddie Simmons

Eddie Simmons — Tue, 23 Dec 2008 10:13:30 +0000

I am sick of all the pondering if the video is real I saw it on LiveLeak.com. It is REAL man no blocked footage. There is no way to rationalize this. LIke on other sites you eat meat everyday. Yeah but I didn't kill the animal you dumb ppl. What the hell is this world man. This guy is the devil this is not rationalization. This guy needs to go to hell.

By: Mick Malloy

Mick Malloy — Wed, 10 Dec 2008 07:39:33 +0000

The criminal, David Mortari, Marine, Soldier, loser, coward or whatever needs to be publicly identified and humiliated in ways the military and government won't as they would like nothing more than to bury this as though it never happend.
True, ignorant, cowardly scum like David Mortari have managed to worm their way into the military but only due to much reduced selection standards and a crippling lack of potential recuits who now realise that to join up is to be screwed over big time – denied discharge after your agreed term under stop loss, high probability of mental or physical injury and the prospect of death for no good reason, dying for a pack of lies in essence.
President Elect Obama need to take hold of the situation and stop the rot as soon as he takes office.
Evacuate from Iraq, bolster the effort in Afghanistan, gain public support for the righteous war in the correct place and bring credibility and honour back to the U.S. Military.
Hillbilly trash Like David Mortari and his pals are the product of the decline of the USA as a world power, morally, militarily and in the respect the rest of the world once had in us.

By: BackwaterBen

BackwaterBen — Thu, 24 Jul 2008 00:16:14 +0000

Hey folks how about we take a deep breath and read what we are writing?
I for one can not stand the painting of all military persons with the same brush. What this marine (not soldier) did to that puppy, if true, is horrible! However what some of you are saying is even worst! How can you blame all the people in all the military service because of the alleged act of one person. That is like saying all the people of one race are bad because someone of that race commits a crime. Of course when that person is arrested, many of you who are calling all military people dog killers. Will say that the person is a product of this “rotten” country and the bad guy had to go to crime because of society. Or because President Bush is to blame.
Yes, if this is a true video, the marine who allegedly did this to the puppy should be dishonorably removed from the marines and put into a cell next to Vick! However you people that are blaming the entire military and President Bush and the Country of America for this alleged puppy abuse are just as bad as the marine alleged to have done this! I know you will now attack me for my comments, and I can take the heat. What I would like you to do is think about what you are going to say. I know some of you will not, but others will. So go for it.
I am an AMERICAN and I love this country! I also believe that people need to take responsibility for there actions.
It use to be that way years ago, but now no matter what happens in some peoples lives, it is not their fault, it is this rotten country, or President Bush or the guy down the street or the cop or the mayor or the post office, anything or anyone but themselves!

By: alex can

alex can — Thu, 12 Jun 2008 01:14:49 +0000

War brutalises every one involved. I don’t in any way condone or minimise this act but what the marine has seen probably makes this look inconsequential. The murders in Haditha seem to have had less of an impact in the world than this barbaric act. The real criminals are the ones who sent this young guy there (based on a lie) in the first place.

By: Keith

Keith — Sat, 31 May 2008 18:14:14 +0000

I spoke to an American friend of mine who estimates that most American Marines are on at least their second or third tour either in Afagahanistan or Iraq. No matter where these soldiers move to afterwards PTSD wont go away. My personal experience of PTSD was when i joined the Parachute Regiment in the mid eighties. All of my instructors were Falklands veterens. Back then we just thought that several of our Corporals were just mad, looking back at it now it’s obvious where their issues lie.

I do see what you mean though Ricky, there is always the chance he is just a piece of shit stationed in Hawai!!!!

By: Ricky

Ricky — Fri, 30 May 2008 20:02:16 +0000

Keith

Werent theses soldiers or marines not in Hawai, is it a war zone at the moment?

By: Keith

Keith — Fri, 30 May 2008 00:15:23 +0000

War places great strain on all parties involved. The moraly weak are the first to crack, asserting their dominance on the physicaly weaker than themselves. My greatest concern when seeing this sort of conduct is not the welfare of the puppy. It is the fact that this individual will, as his “condition” develops, take to inflicting similar or worse injuries on innocent civiliands or pow’s like a duck to water!
Ronnie Brit…. to say your comment is ill-informed is a slight understatement to say the least!!!

By: ronnie brit

ronnie brit — Mon, 26 May 2008 11:10:52 +0000

its no suprise you all ought to hang your heads in shame you americans,this is typical of the scum you are bringing up,all the world seems to want to be a yank.and look at whats happened to itin the uk.gun crime stabbings and gangs,all copied from yankee films.these scum that threw the puppy are typical yankee soldiers i hope you are all proud

By: angela

angela — Wed, 30 Apr 2008 08:03:41 +0000

havent seen the video someone told me about this and i wanted to post a comment, this is a very sick individual who has the cheek to call himself a marine???? surely this isnt what they are trained to do? im sure he will get what he deserves maybe a bomb that blows all his limbs off !! what more can i say hes a very disturbed individual. dont worry folks he WILL GET WHAT HE DESERVES. . .

By: Blackie

Blackie — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 15:43:59 +0000

This is very bad, however there is more behind this: Those young soldiers are deliberatly being de-humanised by this war in which, BTW, many humans and children are suffering too.

Eventualy they will come back to the ‘Western World’ and be seeking jobs, perhaps in the police forces. The future does not look good for humanity.

See UN Agenda 21 and Alan Watt, of Cutting through the matrix.com, for more information about this and what we might do to stop it.